Skip to content

Differences Between Helical Piers and Push Piers for Residential Properties

The Differences Between Helical Piers and Push Piers for Residential Properties

When it comes to foundation repair on residential properties, two commonly used solutions are Helical Piers and Push Piers. Both are effective in stabilizing and supporting homes with foundation issues, but they are designed for different situations and have distinct advantages. Understanding the differences between these two types of piers can help homeowners make an informed decision about which solution is best suited for their specific foundation needs.

Helical Piers: Precision and Versatility

Helical Piers, also known as screw piles, are designed with helices or screw-like plates attached to a central shaft. These plates allow the pier to be screwed into the ground like a corkscrew, creating a deep, stable anchor point in the soil. The installation process involves rotating the pier into the ground until it reaches the desired depth and resistance, at which point it is anchored securely.

Key Advantages of Helical Piers:

  1. Versatility in Soil Conditions: One of the primary benefits of Helical Piers is their ability to be used in a wide range of soil conditions. Because they can be installed to different depths and angles, they are particularly useful in areas with unstable or variable soil, such as clay, sand, or loose fill. The helical design allows the pier to penetrate these challenging soils and reach deeper, more stable layers.
  2. Minimal Disturbance: The installation of Helical Piers is relatively quick and requires less heavy equipment compared to other foundation repair methods. This means less disruption to the property and surrounding landscape. Since no large excavations are needed, the installation process is clean and efficient, making it ideal for residential properties where homeowners want to minimize the impact on their yard.
  3. Immediate Load-Bearing Capacity: Once installed, Helical Piers are immediately capable of bearing the load of the structure. This means that homeowners can see immediate results in terms of stabilization and support, without having to wait for the soil to settle or cure.
  4. Precision in Installation: Helical Piers offer precise control during installation, as the torque applied can be monitored to ensure the pier is anchored at the correct depth and resistance. This precision makes them an excellent choice for projects where exact specifications are critical, such as in lighter structures or when stabilizing specific sections of a foundation.

Helical Piers are often the preferred choice for new construction projects, additions, and for stabilizing existing foundations in areas with challenging soil conditions. Their versatility and immediate load-bearing capability make them a reliable and effective solution for a wide range of foundation issues.

Push Piers: Strength and Depth

Push Piers, also known as resistance piers, are designed to be driven into the ground using the weight of the structure they are supporting. Unlike Helical Piers, which are screwed into the soil, Push Piers are hydraulically driven straight down until they reach bedrock or a stable soil layer. This process uses the existing weight of the building to push the piers deeper into the ground, providing strong, deep support.

Key Advantages of Push Piers:

  1. Ideal for Heavy Structures: Push Piers are particularly well-suited for supporting heavy structures. The weight of the building provides the necessary force to drive the piers deep into the ground, ensuring that they reach a stable layer of soil or bedrock. This makes Push Piers an excellent choice for larger, heavier homes or buildings that require deep foundational support.
  2. Deep Foundation Support: Because Push Piers are driven down to bedrock or a stable soil layer, they provide a deep and permanent solution to foundation settlement issues. This deep anchoring ensures long-term stability and prevents further movement, even in the face of shifting soils or changes in moisture levels.
  3. Effective for Settling Foundations: Push Piers are commonly used in situations where a foundation has already begun to settle. As the piers are driven deeper, they lift and stabilize the foundation, potentially even restoring it to its original level. This lifting capability makes Push Piers an effective solution for homes that have experienced significant settlement and need to be raised back to their proper elevation.
  4. Minimal Site Disruption: Similar to Helical Piers, Push Piers require minimal excavation and disturbance to the property. The installation process is relatively quick, with most of the work happening beneath the surface, leaving the yard and landscaping largely untouched.

Push Piers are often the preferred choice for existing structures that have experienced foundation settlement, particularly those with heavy loads. Their ability to reach bedrock and provide deep, permanent support makes them a reliable solution for long-term stability.

Choosing the Right Solution

Both Helical Piers and Push Piers offer significant benefits for residential foundation repair, but the choice between the two depends largely on the specific circumstances of the property.

  • Soil Conditions: Helical Piers are more versatile and can be used in a variety of soil conditions, making them ideal for properties with challenging or variable soil. Push Piers, on the other hand, are best suited for stable soil conditions where deep support is needed.
  • Structure Weight: The weight of the structure is another important factor. Push Piers are generally better for heavier structures, as the weight of the building is used to drive the piers into the ground. Helical Piers are more adaptable and can be used for lighter structures or in situations where precise installation is required.
  • Installation Goals: If immediate load-bearing capacity and minimal site disturbance are priorities, Helical Piers may be the better choice. However, if deep foundational support and the ability to lift and stabilize a settling foundation are needed, Push Piers may be more appropriate.

Ultimately, both Helical Piers and Push Piers provide reliable, long-term solutions for foundation repair. Homeowners should consult with a foundation repair specialist to determine the best option for their specific needs, ensuring the stability and safety of their home for years to come.

Foundation Rescue Supply is one of the nation’s largest distributors for residential and commercial foundation repair products. Contact us today for a contractor referral or for assistance bidding a project.